Monday, June 4, 2018

The Disorganized Organization

The Disorganized Organization

    For the first time in my life, I fell like the Cincinnati Reds are a train wreck. Now I see others feel the same way, some in the baseball pundit universe are starting to talk about it also this morning. I don't blame the players, the manager, or the coaches. None of these make the decision to hire, fire, and acquire players. That falls squarely on the shoulders of the front office, period! As of June 4th 2018, the Reds front office is and has been for sometime in complete disarray. Not a few bad decisions, but consistently bad decisions for quite a few years now.

   Here is a portion of the new owners statement from Casellini and the two Williams brothers.“We will build one of the most respected organizations in baseball. As partners in other successful baseball organizations we know how it’s done. We will build a winning management team by putting the right people in the right positions with the right resources to win. We will foster a winning attitude and culture.” 

  With all that said and done, when has this been done? The owners select the front office, who scout, hire and fire players and management in order to get the BEST team on the field in order to do what the owners statement pledges to do. First the owners have to place the right people in the front office. With the exception of 1 year of Wayne Krivsky,  the Reds front office has been dominated by Walt Jocketty, and Dick Williams to the present.  Jocketty virtually trained Williams for the GM role. There are many comparisons of baseball to a human body. The body does the work, the brain (front office) organizes and directs the vital organs (field management) and directs the rest of the body (players) to action. The better the brain, the better the body works.

  For our purposes we will concentrate on the brain (front office). It is here where an organization becomes organized or disorganized. If there is a failure to field the proper players, it is the front office. If the right manger isn't there, it is on the front office. The only functions a field manager really has is making a lineup card, making some on field decisions, and setting the tone for the team. For instance Brian Price was very Dusty Baker-esque in his laid back manager style. Well Dusty was successful, and look at Price! Maybe Dusty was a better manager, but the front office should have seen the dynamic in place.  Dusty was laid back, Jack McKeon was laid back, even Davey Johnson was laid back in his managerial style. All but Price had one thing that greatly helped them, an enforcer, or good cop bad cop situation.  This works very well in a baseball dynamic. With the advent of huge salaries, and 100 page contracts, the inevitable ego thing popped it's ugly head up. With a laid back manager, he soothes the ego, spouts wisdom, and is liked. What the laid back manager loses in his role, the enforcer gains by keeping peace, sets an action tone and winning tone for the team to play to max potential. Dusty had Rolen and Chris Spier, McKeon had Greg Vaughn, and Johnson had Barry Larkin. You can be a laid back manager when you have an enforcer to counter to keep a balance all winning clubs have. I saw this, you have seen this, but the Reds front office did not, so Price was doomed from the start, no enforcer.  Both Jocketty and Williams should have seen this coming and reacted to it, it's their job, but no one did.

   Some decisions may look bad in a rebuild, but are good for the long run. For instance moving Cody Reed and others up and down the last 3 years may look disorganized, but they are looking at and evaluating talent to see who should be the piece to add to make a solid team. I am not talking about that here, nor will I go over the myriad of dumb moves Jocketty and Williams have made. If you are in a rebuild, you must evaluate talent, and get MLB work in for new talent to evaluate them. You also have to get reps in for the talent you already have.  This is where disorganization creeps in. If we are doing that, then why (1) is Amir Garrett still in the bullpen with a 1.99 ERA when our 5 starters have only 2 with a 4+ ERA, and 3 with a 5+ ERA?(2) Why was Jeesse Winker banched with a .247 BA, when Duvall is at .180, and Hamilton is at .200 and not stealing bases, and making gaffes in the outfield? (3) Matt Harvey??? Bad trade, and no trade bait there, and why wouldn't we have Garrett, Lorenzen, or Stephenson in that place.  (4) Blandino is off the radar after a great start with only a small sample to evaluate. This is not how many other teams successfully rebuild, the blueprint is there, but the Reds Front office has not opened it yet.

  One thing Dick Williams seems to have learned from Jocketty is terrible (not bad) trade timing. It seems the Reds front office has an algorithm to predict the minimum to get out of a player, and then act on it!  Cozart is a classic case. He entered his last contract year, and we waited until he was injured to try to move him, and then ate any value he had by getting NOTHING out of him, and this has happened consistently for the last few years. Yes this happens occasionally with other clubs, but none consistently except the Reds. Other teams view us as patsies on trades, if we get nothing, then we only get a bare minimum out of a player, i.e. Chapman, Cueto, Frazier and others. Again, symptoms of disorganization. 

   

  The biggest problem the Reds have is developing talent, especially pitchers. Looking today at mock drafts, almost every site mentions this when talking about a pitcher the Reds might take. We amassed all these "live arms" from bad trades, and what do we have to show for it? Finnegan, Reed, Lamb (now gone) are busts, high ERA in AAA, and worse in MLB play. The Reds took a Mike Leake style player (Finnegan) and devovled him into a AAA loser, and this man has pitched in a World Series successfully.  WE have fostered a tolerance for losing that a 5+ ERA feels entitled to play in the Majors! (See Bailey and Finnegan).  Then in my opinion the Reds committed the worst piece of front office shenanigans after they fired Price! The future rotation has 3 pieces set now, Castillo, Mahle, and Romano. What do all of them have in common? Pat Kelley and Danny Darwin at AA Pensacola. When Price was fired, Pat Kelly became the bench coach, and Darwin the pitching coach. The ONLY bright spot for development (especially pitching) was Pensacola. When Price was fired, we then brought up the ONLY developmental team we had, to the big league, where we were in a rebuilding, admittedly losing season anyway. That begs the question, who is developing our kids in Pensacola? Not Kelley or Darwin! Again, on the front office.

  

  I read last year on a St. Louis fan board, and I am paraphrasing here " Walt Jocketty performed his best work for the Cardinals by dismantling the Cincinnati Reds as GM". Jocketty whether knowingly on purpose, or by complete ineptness started this downward spiral, with no end in site. I do not subscribe to the knowingly did it camp. I believe Jocketty is the Tom Landry of baseball. Once a good executive, baseball passed him by. Things changed and he did not keep up. Metrics, new ways of evaluation, differing market condition, he did not keep up on any, and it hurt the Reds deeply, organization wise. So now we have the protege' of Jocketty, skilled in his way that has passed on by, who only knows the Jocketty skill (or unskilled) mindset, one that has shown to be a failure from the start. The Cincinnati Reds need a sweep, not on the field, but in the front office. The problem is Williams will be there until things are so egregious that Castellini has to sell due to a complete lack of attendance forces him to.  Williams father and uncle are owners, and top executives of the Reds. Until this changes, the Reds are a self exiled losing team, destined to lose a record amount of games year after year. You can transplant organs, and fix arms and legs. The brain cannot be transplanted, and very rarely fixed, so the allegorical connection says we cannot be fixed until the front office is fixed and overhauled.  Even a football icon like Tom Landry was fired, and I can only hope that comes true for the Reds.



 

 

    


 

 



Tuesday, May 22, 2018

Moneyball! Part 1

   Back when I was a kid, we played baseball for fun, and a love of the game. Yes, and when I was a kid the owners literally "owned" players. 

   When the Curt Flood court case ended, we thought a wrong was righted, and things would go on in the same way in all other facets of the game. WRONG! The first problem I saw as a 
kid was that Pete Rose was going to leave the Reds, and go to Philadelphia! This really got to me, as well as most Cincinnati Reds fans. Wow! Players usually stayed with the team they were playing with, but now they could go anywhere! Team owner loyalty (and there was) and player loyalty (and there was) were now thrown out the window. It started right there with the transformation of baseball as we used to know it. Suddenly, baseball was not important anymore, the money was, and it gets worse everyday. 
 
   There are many reasons for this complete change from the nations pastime  to a sport struggling to stay alive. The old saying of "Money is the root of all evil" is alive and well, and totally applicable to baseball. Players started making more money, and that was good, for awhile. Then desperate owner had to jack up concession and ticket prices to keep up. On top of that, over a period of 2 decades, player salaries were outperforming revenues. There is a direct correlation between player salaries uptick, and a smaller gate (attendance) each year. 
 
   Another thing playing out since I was a kid, is the society norms we have. Instead of playing the game for the game, it has become a system that money rules, there is no loyalty anywhere,  and the game be damned! In all negotiations between player and owner, have you ever seen a point of discussion on helping the game become the winner it used to be? Hell no! It's all about money, compensation, and who gets what of the pot! All the stupid rule changes to "pick up the pace" of the game, are only treating an arterial bleed with a band-aid! Most cannot afford to take a family of 4 to a ballpark.  We used to go to 15-25 Reds games a year when I was growing up, now, maybe once a year. And money has tarnished much more!
 
   I played A ball, and semi-pro for three years. I would have played for 50,000 a year, point blank, anywhere! Moneyball now rewards the mediocre and non performing like never before. I would have thought you insane if you told me that in a few years, players would be rewarded by making a minimum salary of 610,000 dollars a year. How about Homer Bailey? Mesoraco, Bobby Bonilla (remember him?), get paid tens of millions a year to do absolutely nothing? Bonilla make 1.19 million a year through 2035, he "retired" in 2001, but gets paid until 2035! We have .200 hitters (and less) making 5-8 million a year, that is just unacceptable. 
 
The Agents, and owners have played us to the hilt. In Part 2, I will cover the agents, in Part 3 the owners, Part 4 will cover baseball vs. other sports, and Part 5 some common sense means to bring THE GAME of baseball back from the brink.
 
  
 

The Disorganized Organization

The Disorganized Organization     For the first time in my life, I fell like the Cincinnati Reds are a train wreck. Now I see others f...